Private matchmaking
Private matchmaking in Long Island & the Hamptons

A better way to meet someone in Long Island.

Private matchmaking is a serious investment. We suggest most singles start with eharmony, which matches you on compatibility rather than swipes, and come to us when they want a matchmaker working for them personally.

Get matched on eharmony →

No cost to sign up. Heads up: links to eharmony are affiliate links, so we may earn a commission if you join. Your price doesn't change.

Where we suggest you begin

The closest thing to matchmaking you can do yourself.

Plenty of our clients tried eharmony first, and many people find the right person there without ever needing us. Here's why we're comfortable recommending it.

1

Matching that starts with you

The questionnaire covers how you live, what you value and what you want from a partner, so the people you see are chosen for fit rather than looks alone.

2

Made for long-term dating

eharmony is aimed at singles who want something lasting, which is exactly who we work with too.

3

Low risk

Joining is free, so you can see your matches around Long Island before deciding whether to pay for anything.

Your options in Long Island

How the options compare.

Each has its place. The right one depends on how much time you have and how much of the work you want to hand over.

Swipe apps

  • How you meet peopleYou scroll and swipe through profiles yourself
  • Ideal if you wantMeeting lots of people quickly
  • Time it takesA lot
  • What you payFree tier plus paid extras

eharmonyStart here

  • How you meet peopleSuggested from a detailed compatibility questionnaire
  • Ideal if you wantA serious relationship without paying for a matchmaker
  • Time it takesModerate
  • What you payFree sign-up; subscription to message

Private matchmaker

  • How you meet peopleA matchmaker handpicks and vets each introduction
  • Ideal if you wantBusy people who want it done for them, discreetly
  • Time it takesLow
  • What you payA significant investment, usually thousands

Start with eharmony →

Long Island & the Hamptons

Dating in Long Island

Between the North Shore, the South Shore and summers out east, Long Island singles cover a lot of ground. Meeting the right person shouldn't depend on luck.

Private matchmaking

When you'd rather not do it yourself.

For singles who value discretion and their time, we offer one-to-one matchmaking: we get to know you, search on your behalf and only introduce people we think are worth meeting. Places are limited, so we work by application.

  • Feedback after every date so each introduction gets closer
  • No public profile, ever
  • Complete discretion from the first conversation
  • A search that fits around your schedule
FAQ

Common questions

We work right across Long Island & the Hamptons, from The Hamptons to Oyster Bay.
Fees vary with the scope of the search. As a guide, private matchmaking usually costs thousands rather than hundreds, and we explain everything up front, with no obligation.
A personal matchmaker is a big commitment, and many people find someone without one. eharmony works on a similar idea, matching on compatibility, so we think it's the right first step. Our private service is there when you want more help.
Yes, you can join and see who you're matched with for free. Full messaging is part of eharmony's paid membership, which eharmony prices itself.
No. The Long Island Matchmaker is independent. We're a paid eharmony affiliate, which means we may earn a commission if you join through our links. That never changes what you pay.

The right person is probably closer than you think.

Begin with eharmony's free compatibility quiz, or tell us about yourself and we'll take it from there.

Get matched on eharmony →

Heads up: links to eharmony are affiliate links, so we may earn a commission if you join. Your price doesn't change. eharmony is a trademark of its owner, which isn't affiliated with this site beyond our referral partnership.

© 2026 The Long Island Matchmaker · Privacy